home
animation

projects
image manipulation
interactive whiteboards
interactive exercises
presentations
multimedia tutorials
other tutorials
art links
gallery
about



 

 

 

 

Home - Animation - Video - Projects - Image Manipulation - IWBs - Interactive - Presentations - Multimedia Tutorials - Other Tutorials - Art Links - Gallery - About

 Art sleuths

Aim
Rationale
Brief 1: find the mystery painting
Search strategy
Judge reliability
Brief 2: art sleuth websearch
Useful web links
Answer to brief 1
Footnote

    

Art sleuth button

Aim

To promote and develop effective search skills and critical judgment when using the internet by:

  • choosing a suitable search engine
  • constructing effective search criteria
  • saving links
  • evaluating the reliability and usefulness of information
  • selecting the most appropriate site(s)
Art sleuth button

Rationale

Although it is only one source of information for art and design among many, the internet is acknowledged to be a significant research tool for contextual studies: more widely accessible and cheaper than art books and catalogues, constantly updated, a gateway to the most contemporary practice as to the most established, to the least familiar as to the most documented, it opens the doors of galleries, museums, libraries, collections and artists' studios from any place and at any time. Yet teachers frequently express frustration because pupils indiscriminately cut and paste  chunks of text from websites with no evidence that they have understood or even read the information.  Effective internet research skills are instrumental to fostering independent, critical learners and thinkers in a technological age; but, as with other skills, they need to be actively taught. 

School art: what's in it? Exploring visual arts in secondary schools, by Dick Downing and Ruth Watson (NFER Nov 2004) commissioned by Arts Council England in association with Tate, scrutinized the content of the key stage 3 and 4 art curriculum, with particular reference to the inclusion of contemporary art practice. The report found that the creative use of ICT in art departments was limited, in contrast to the widespread use of the internet for contextual research. However, the report also suggested that pupils are not taught the skills they need to use the internet critically or effectively. Don't assume that they are learning these skills in other lessons: from the start make it a priority to help them develop key internet information skills and strategies relevant to art and design.

Top

Art sleuth button Brief 1: find the mystery painting

For a project on self-portraits you have been asked to research a particular painting for homework. Unfortunately, you didn't make a note of the title and you can only remember a few details - the artist is Mexican and the painting is a double portrait. Can you work it out? You can only use the internet to find the information you need.


Art sleuth button

Search strategy - 4 steps to successful sleuthing

1Choose a suitable search tool

There are three main types of internet search tool:

  • Search Engines - trawl millions of websites using 'robots', 'web crawlers' or 'spiders'> They are programs that roam the internet automatically storing information about each page they visit, and are useful for finding specific pieces of information. Three of the most popular search engines are: Google, Altavista, Ask Jeeves

  • Web Directories  - these group websites by subject and are built by people searching the internet, not robots. They are useful when you need to find both popular and serious sites. You select a category e.g. Arts, Visual Arts, Art History, or Painting, and "drill down" from there by choosing appropriate sub-categories. Popular examples of directories are Yahoo and Search. The most comprehensive is The Open Directory Project, which is compiled by a vast global network of volunteers. Many search engines are powered by the ODP.

  • Subject Gateways or Portals - these link to a variety of sites on a specific topic or subject area and are compiled by universities, colleges and other specialist organisations. They are a reliable source for homework and project research. Popular gateways for art and design are Artifact, Artcyclopedia, World Wide Arts Resources, and The Global Gallery

Tip: make shortcuts to your preferred search engine or directory by Adding to Favorites (PC) or Bookmarking (Mac), so that you don't have to keep typing in the URL. To make it even easier you can download from some search engines like Google a dedicated search toolbar that always sits in your browser window.

Google toolbar

Activity 1: Try typing in what you know about the painting (e.g. Mexican artist) into three different search engines and compare (a) the number of results you get and (b) the website that tops the list. What differences are there?

Sleuthing activitySearch strategies worksheet Word document [69KB] PDF [67KB]

Top

2Refine your search strategy

 To focus your search more and narrow down the results you should:

  • list a few possible keywords e.g. self-portrait, painting, Mexican, double

  • avoid vague or general terms e.g. 'painter' is more specific than 'artist'

  • check the spelling of your key words

  • combine keywords by using BOOLEAN operators, which are connecting words like AND, OR, NOT. These indicate that another key word should be included, should be excluded, or may be included e.g. Mexican AND painter AND self-portrait OR portrait NOT decorator

  • use your chosen search engine's Advanced Search to apply criteria that narrow the search. Google's Advanced Search finds results with 'all of the words', 'the exact phrase', and with 'any of the words', as well as 'without the words'. When you do find a useful web page, the final two advanced search fields in Google are for a Page Specific search: they allow you to 'find pages similar to' or 'find pages linked to' it. Try them - you may find other pages that are just as relevant.

  • type inverted commas "" around an exact phrase to link the words together, so that the engine searches for the whole string, and not separately for each individual word e.g. "double self-portrait" 

Tip: Read through the online Help section of your favourite search engine - different engines work in different ways e.g. Google doesn't recognise BOOLEAN operators; Altavista uses + - instead of AND, NOT

Activity 2: Try using more advanced search criteria e.g. typing "double self-portrait" into a search engine with and without "" , then with other combinations of your key words. The worksheet gives you sleuthing practice with three search engines. If you think you have found the missing painting, you are almost ready to begin the web search.

Sleuthing activitySearch strategies worksheet Word document [69KB] PDF [67KB]

Top

3Save important links

Art sleuths like other researchers must make a careful note of their sources, or where they found their evidence. Open a new document and when you find a useful site which you may need to get information from later, make a shortcut in your browser as at step 1, but also copy and paste the URL from the address bar into your new document. You may also want to make a brief note of why you think it could be useful. Save your document as project_references and keep adding web links to it until the project is finished. This will be the basis of a reference page for your e-portfolio. 

Tip: smart sleuths know that how easy it is to get lost when browsing from site to site - they either use their browser's Back button to find the way back, or they open each link in a new window. To do this right-click on the link (PC), or Control-click on it (Mac), and select Open in New Window from the context menu.

Activity 3: Download a blank template to use for this project and begin adding useful links to it.

Sleuthing activityProject references worksheet Word document [59KB] PDF [47KB]

Top

4Judge how reliable and useful the information is

Millions of new pages are published every day on the internet. The best thing about the web is that anyone can publish anything. The worst thing about the web is that anyone can publish anything ... Not all of the information is reliable or trustworthy; not all of it is up to date. How can you judge what to trust and what is relevant to you? What clues can you find to help? Before you trust the information on a site, ask yourself these eight questions:

  1. Look at the domain name: what does the URL tell you about the site? Would you trust the content more if the URL ended with .org, .gov, .ac or .sch than if it had .com domain name? Why?

  2. Is it clear whose site it is? Does the site have contact information? Does the site belong to an organisation or an individual? Which would you trust more? If it's a personal site, has it been approved by an official organisation? 

  3. Who is the site aimed at? Can you easily deduce who the target audience is? 

  4. What is the site for? Is its purpose clear? Does it do what it says?

  5. Is the information up to date? When was the site made or last updated?

  6. Is the content objective and unbiased? Can you find any examples of personal opinion or subjective ideas? Can statements or facts be easily checked?

  7. Are alternative sources of the same information suggested so you can compare or cross-check e.g. links to sites with similar content?

  8. Is the information useful to you i.e. is it on the topic in question and is it written in a way that you can understand?

Activity 4: Compare two websites using these criteria. Download a Word or PDF version by clicking on the relevant icon. Note that you can type directly into the Word document if you keep it open as you work, then save it to your e-portfolio.

Sleuthing activityReliability and usefulness worksheet Word document [69KB] PDF [92KB]

Top

Art sleuth button

Have you found it yet?

Click on the art sleuths graphic to see if you have found the missing painting.

 

Art sleuth button

Brief 2:art sleuth websearch


Practise your art sleuth skills with a web search to discover more about the mystery painting and the artist. Download a copy to print out or complete electronically for your e-portfolio.
Sleuthing activityFrida Kahlo websearch worksheet Websearch (with extension question)

Word document [70KB] PDF [50KB]

Websearch - suggested answers (guide only)

Word document [97KB] PDF [72KB]


Art sleuth button 

Web links

These links are to activities and web pages that will also help you improve your internet searching skills.

Quick
http://www.quick.org.uk
The Quick (Quality Information Checklist) site is designed to help younger pupils assess the validity and usefulness of information they find on the internet (key stages 2 & 3).

Virtual Training Suite
http://www.vts.ac.uk/tutorial/media
The VTS is a free resource designed to teach internet information skills in a vocational context to young people and adult learners. The "teach yourself" tutorials are organised into subject categories. Art and design students should select the Art, Design and Media tutorials in the Internet for Further Education section.

Albany University Library, State of New York
http://library.albany.edu/internet.choose.html
This page gives useful information to help you select an appropriate search engine for your purpose and explains the different search terms or Boolean operators used by the main engines and directories.

Top

Brief 1 - find the missing painting: answer

The missing painting is called 'The Two Fridas" or "Las Dos Fridas", a double self-portrait of the Mexican artist Frida Kahlo, painted in 1939. Did you find it? The photograph shows the artist in her studio at work on the almost finished painting. 

The Two Fridas Frida painting 'The Two Fridas' - the three Fridas


Flashpoint movie  

Flashpoints are my interactive Flash lesson starters based on a single artwork or theme. Try this Flashpoint about another of Frida's double self-portraits, Tree of Hope.


Footnote

These two A1 size self-portraits by a part-time PRU student, a school refuser, were inspired by Kahlo and their shared love of animals, as she too had numerous exotic pets - the pastel drawing was made in Year 10 and the acrylic painting was her GCSE exam piece. She also made an elaborate relief frame for one of the portraits.

Self-portrait with iguana, parrot and owl (pastel on paper) Self-portrait with camera and parrot (acrylic on board) Leafy frame (mixed media)

Top

© RKM 2002 - 2007

Home - Animation - Video - Projects - Image Manipulation - IWBs - Interactive - Presentations - Multimedia Tutorials - Other Tutorials - Art Links - Gallery - About